Reviews

What actually arrives when you commission a review

Mostly a short video, not a document. Knowing the shape of the thing before you order is how you avoid buying something other than what you pictured.

2 min readReviews

People imagine a written verdict. What arrives is almost always a short vertical video of the judge responding to what you sent, and the gap between those two expectations causes most of the disappointment in this market.

The shape of a clip

Typically a minute or two. Shot vertically, because that is what everything is watched on.

Structure varies by judge and by request, but the common arc is: a reaction to the material, then commentary in the register you asked for, then some form of verdict or sign-off. Some judges score numerically, many do not - a number is not the point of a human review and asking for one sometimes gets you the least interesting version of what that person does.

The material you send shapes it heavily. A brief with something specific in it produces a clip that responds to that specific thing. A brief that says "rate me" produces a generic clip, because you asked a generic question - which is most of what separates a good result from a flat one.

The common categories

Most services group requests into a few registers, and the names are fairly standard across the industry:

SPH - small penis humiliation. A specific and long-established genre with its own conventions. People asking for it usually know exactly what they want, and judges who do it well do it well.

Worship - the opposite register: appreciative, enthusiastic, complimentary.

Honest - a straight assessment without a lean in either direction. Less popular than the other two and more difficult to do well, because there is no register carrying it.

Custom - anything with a scenario or specifics attached.

Picking the right category matters more than the wording of your request. A judge working in the wrong register is doing an impression rather than the thing they are good at.

What you send

Generally a small number of photos and sometimes a short clip, plus written instructions. Limits vary; a handful of images is typical.

More material is not better. A clear brief with two good photos beats a vague brief with six.

How delivery works

The finished file lands somewhere in your account - an orders or collection area - to preview and download.

Worth checking before you buy: whether the file is yours to keep and whether it is served through a permanent URL or a short-lived signed link. The second is the better answer, because a static URL is a permanent public address for a private file. Services differ here and it is rarely advertised; Cock Rate mints links per view rather than exposing files by URL, which is the property to look for.

Also worth knowing before you spend: pricing is quoted per request rather than fixed, so the order of operations is describe, get a price, then decide.

And if you have not settled between a person and an algorithm yet, the difference is worth understanding first - a lot of people commission a human review wanting something an algorithm would have given them faster and cheaper.

Read next

Full archive